24/11/2026 - 12:45 -LECL 61
Gianmarco Luu
(UCLouvain, LIDAM, CORE)
will give a presentation on
Bought but Never Used: Quantity Discounts and Relative Thinking
Abstract:
Quantity discounts are a widespread selling strategy for many goods. By lowering the price of additional units, they can expand sales and benefit consumers. However, authorities are increasingly concerned about their potential harms. Consumers may buy more than they use, resulting in financial losses and environmental waste from unused products.
We study how firms design quantity discounts when consumers differ in their expected use of additional units and some underweight the price of these units. In a rational benchmark, firms use quantity discounts to screen consumers according to their expected use. No consumer buys a unit worth less than its price, and all waste is anticipated by the buyer.
We then introduce relative thinkers (Bushong, Rabin, and Schwartzstein, 2021). They know all prices but underweight the price of the second unit, the more so the larger its discount relative to the first-unit price. We find that two pricing regimes can emerge. In the genuine-discount regime, firms keep the first-unit price at its benchmark level and discount the second unit, but the discount can be deeper or shallower than in the benchmark. In the decoy regime, which arises when relative thinkers are numerous and margins are thin, firms set a first-unit price that nobody pays, simply to make the pack look cheaper. In both regimes, some consumers buy units they value less than their price. Consumer surplus can therefore be negative, and waste can increase. Finally, we examine how restricting quantity discounts affects total welfare. Our results highlight the trade-off policymakers face between protecting consumers and the environment and preserving promotions that benefit consumers.
More information on the speaker